Starfield vs No Man's Sky: Which Should You Buy?
Starfield's PS5 release in April 2026 (with the Free Lanes update and Terran Armada DLC) put it head-to-head with No Man's Sky for the first time on a single console. NMS just shipped its 35th major update (Xeno Arena, April 8, 2026) and continues to be the best comeback story in gaming. Both are space games. Both let you fly between planets. That's where the similarities end.
Here's the honest comparison.
Starfield
No Man's Sky
You're not picking between two space games — you're picking between two completely different fantasies. Starfield is Fallout-in-space: faction questlines, hand-crafted story content, RPG character systems. No Man's Sky is sandbox-in-space: emergent exploration, base building, multiplayer creativity, infinite procedural worlds. Both are good. They overlap less than you'd think.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Starfield | No Man's Sky | |
|---|---|---|
| Original release | September 2023 | August 2016 |
| 2026 status | Free Lanes + Terran Armada DLC | Update 6.33 (Xeno Arena) |
| Platforms | PC, Xbox, PS5 | PC, Xbox, PS4/5, Switch 1+2, Mac, VR |
| Price | $69.99 + $9.99 DLC | $59.99 (often $24-30 on sale) |
| Core fantasy | Bethesda RPG in space | Procedural exploration sandbox |
| Story | Hand-crafted, faction questlines, NG+ canon | Light, optional, atmospheric |
| Planets | 1,000+ procedural + handcrafted hubs | 18 quintillion procedural |
| Multiplayer | Single player only | Up to 32 players, base sharing |
| Building | Outposts (limited) | Deep base building, ship building, freighter customization |
| Update cadence | Periodic patches + paid DLC | Free updates every 3-4 months |
| VR support | No | Yes |
What Each Game Is
Starfield
Starfield is Bethesda's space RPG — Fallout/Skyrim DNA transposed to a galaxy. Hand-crafted faction questlines (UC Vanguard, Crimson Fleet, Trackers Alliance), a main storyline with NG+ canonization, ship building and customization, character skills and progression. The 2026 PS5 release ships with the free Free Lanes update (planet-to-planet flight, autopilot, X-Tech resource) and the optional $9.99 Terran Armada DLC. PS5 Pro version is the best-looking console release of the game by a clear margin.
No Man's Sky
No Man's Sky launched in 2016 to infamous backlash, and Hello Games has spent the last decade turning it into one of the most beloved sandbox games ever made. Now at update 6.33 with 35 major named updates, it offers true infinite procedural exploration, deep base building, ship and freighter customization, multiplayer for up to 32 players, regular Expedition events, VR support, and updates every 3-4 months — all free, no paid DLC. It's the rare game that actually delivered on the impossible promises of its launch.
How to Decide
PICK STARFIELD IF...
- You want a hand-crafted RPG experience with story, characters, and quest design
- You loved Fallout 4 or Skyrim and want that in space
- Single-player narrative content matters most to you
- You own a PS5 Pro and want a showcase title
- You don't care about VR, building, or multiplayer
PICK NO MAN'S SKY IF...
- Sandbox creativity matters more than story
- You want to play with friends — multiplayer is huge here
- You own VR — NMS is one of the best VR games ever made
- You play across multiple platforms (NMS supports cross-save and cross-play)
- You want a game that updates forever for free
- Budget matters — NMS is regularly $24-30 on sale
The Bottom Line
These games are sold as competitors but they barely overlap. Starfield is for the player who finishes Bethesda games for the questlines. No Man's Sky is for the player who builds bases and shares screenshots.
If you're forced to pick one based purely on value: No Man's Sky. It's cheaper, runs everywhere, supports VR and multiplayer, and updates for free. If you want story-driven RPG content specifically: Starfield. If you can afford both: they're complementary, not redundant — get both and play them in different moods.
Make Your Pick
Whichever way you go, here are the best places to buy:
STARFIELD ON AMAZON NO MAN'S SKY ON AMAZONAs an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.
RELATED ON THE MANUAL
- Should You Buy Starfield on PS5? — Full Starfield verdict
- Best PS5 Games to Buy Right Now
- Best New RPGs of 2026