CONSOLE VS CONSOLE · WII TURNS 20 IN 2026

Wii vs Wii U: Which Nintendo Console Is the Better Retro Buy?

The Wii turns 20 this year. Its awkward, commercially disappointing sequel has aged into a genuinely interesting collector's console.

Library Size vs Library Quality

Wii's library is enormous thanks to its massive commercial success, ranging from genre-defining first-party titles to a huge volume of budget shovelware, requiring some curation to find the good stuff. Wii U sold far worse commercially, but that same commercial failure means its first-party library (Super Mario 3D World, Breath of the Wild's original release, Mario Kart 8) is comparatively small and unusually consistent in quality.

Backward Compatibility

Early Wii models can play GameCube discs directly, a meaningful factor covered in more depth elsewhere on this site. Wii U, in turn, plays most Wii discs and Wii Virtual Console content where previously purchased, giving it a layered backward-compatibility story across three console generations in one box.

Which to Buy

If you want the broadest library and GameCube compatibility on select models, Wii is the more essential purchase. If you want a smaller, more consistently excellent first-party library plus layered backward compatibility, Wii U is a genuinely underrated pickup that's grown in collector esteem since its commercial disappointment.

Some links on this page are eBay and Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, ShouldIBuyThisGame.com may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.