FOUNDATIONAL COLLECTING / WHERE TO START

Atari 2600 vs NES: Where Should a New Retro Collector Start?

Two genuinely foundational consoles, but only one of them is still being manufactured brand new.

Historical Significance vs Practical Playability

Atari 2600 predates NES by years and is genuinely responsible for establishing the home console market in the first place, but its library reflects the era's much more primitive design conventions — many games are simple by modern standards and better appreciated as history than as ongoing entertainment. NES's library holds up dramatically better as actual games people still want to play, not just study.

The Atari 2600+ Changes the Calculus

Atari has put the 2600 back into production as the Atari 2600+, a new-manufacture reissue that plays original cartridges and includes modern conveniences like HDMI output, removing the "will this 45-year-old hardware still work" question entirely for buyers who want the format without the risk. NES has no equivalent official reissue at this price point, so buyers are working with original hardware only.

Which to Buy First

For actual ongoing playability, NES is the stronger first purchase. For historical completeness and an easy, low-risk way to experience where console gaming started, the new Atari 2600+ is a genuinely good entry point specifically because it sidesteps original-hardware reliability questions.

Some links on this page are eBay and Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, ShouldIBuyThisGame.com may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.