CONSOLE VS CONSOLE / CROSS-GENERATION

SNES vs N64: Which Nintendo Classic Should You Own?

Two consoles, one company, two completely different eras of what Nintendo does best.

Two Different Eras of Nintendo Design

SNES represents the peak of Nintendo's 2D craftsmanship — Super Mario World, A Link to the Past, and Super Metroid are still reference points for how those genres are designed today. N64 represents Nintendo figuring out 3D from scratch, in real time, with Super Mario 64 and Ocarina of Time essentially writing the rulebook that 3D platformers and action-adventure games still follow.

Practical Differences That Matter

SNES has a bigger library overall and, on average, cheaper individual cartridges since more were manufactured across its longer, more successful commercial run. N64's controller is the bigger practical consideration — its analog stick is a mechanical wear part that loosens with age, so budget for a controller in good condition rather than assuming any unit works like new. Both consoles use cartridges, so neither has the disc-rot concerns that affect PS1, Saturn, or Dreamcast.

Which to Buy First

If you want the deeper, cheaper library and the genre-defining 2D classics, start with SNES. If four-player local multiplayer and the jump to 3D matter more to you, start with N64 — just factor controller condition into your budget. Most Nintendo collectors end up wanting both fairly quickly, since they don't really compete for the same games.

Some links on this page are eBay and Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, ShouldIBuyThisGame.com may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.