GAME VS GAME / METROID SHOWDOWN · METROID TURNS 40 IN 2026
Super Metroid vs Metroid Prime: 2D vs 3D Metroid
Both entries are regularly cited as the best in their respective sub-genres. Both are also genuinely expensive collector cartridges.
Defining Their Respective Eras
Super Metroid perfected the atmospheric, interconnected map design that gave the "Metroidvania" genre its name, and its influence on 2D exploration games remains massive to this day. Metroid Prime pulled off something many thought impossible — translating that same exploratory, isolating atmosphere into a first-person 3D game without turning it into a straightforward shooter, a genuinely rare design achievement.
Collector Reality
Both games are among the pricier standard cartridges/discs in their respective console libraries specifically because of their enduring critical reputations, and demand has stayed consistently high rather than fading. Super Metroid's SNES cartridge carries no unusual risk beyond normal cartridge condition; Metroid Prime's GameCube disc is subject to the same general optical media aging concerns as any 6th-gen disc.
Which to Buy First
If you want the genre-defining 2D original, start with Super Metroid. If you want to see how that same design philosophy translated into 3D, start with Metroid Prime. Both are considered must-owns by Metroid fans, and Metroid's 40th anniversary this year is a fitting reason to pick up either.
Where to Buy
Some links on this page are eBay and Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, ShouldIBuyThisGame.com may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.