HANDHELD VS HANDHELD / 7TH GENERATION
PSP vs Nintendo DS: The Best 7th-Gen Handheld to Buy Now
Handheld collecting demand has grown steadily, and these two remain the defining rivals of their generation.
Design Philosophy: Two Screens vs One Powerful One
DS built its entire identity around dual screens and touch input, unlocking genres and mechanics (puzzle games, DS-native RPG interfaces, the entire brain-training wave) that simply didn't exist on a single-screen handheld. PSP went the opposite direction — a single high-resolution screen and console-comparable power that made it a genuinely strong home for ports and original titles that looked and played closer to a home console experience.
Media and Format Considerations
PSP doubled as a portable media player, supporting music and video playback via its UMD format and memory stick storage, a real selling point at the time. DS relied on cartridges exclusively, which means no disc-based degradation concerns the way PSP's UMD format can have, though UMD wear is generally a smaller concern than optical discs on home consoles.
Which to Buy
DS is the broader, safer first purchase given its larger and more varied library and simpler cartridge-based reliability. PSP is very much worth owning alongside it for its stronger action and RPG library and console-like presentation — the two rarely compete for the same games, so owning both is common among 7th-gen handheld collectors.
Some links on this page are eBay and Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, ShouldIBuyThisGame.com may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.
Used and collector-market research
Check current asking inventory separately from completed sales. Sold results are usually better evidence of the market, but exact model, originality, condition, included parts and shipping can change the comparison.
Affiliate disclosure: qualifying marketplace purchases may earn this site a commission at no extra cost to you. Completed sales are research examples, not a formal appraisal.