POKÉMON BUYER'S GUIDE / THIRD VERSIONS RANKED
Every Pokémon "Third Version" Ranked: Crystal, Emerald, Platinum & More
A buyer's guide to the enhanced versions worth paying a premium for, and the ones you can safely skip.
| Enhanced Version | What It Added | Buy Priority |
|---|---|---|
| Pokémon Platinum | Distortion World, Giratina Origin Forme, rebalanced pacing | High |
| Pokémon Emerald | Battle Frontier, both legendaries & villain teams | High |
| Pokémon Crystal | Animated sprites, female protagonist option, Battle Tower | High |
| Ultra Sun / Ultra Moon | Necrozma subplot, Ultra Megalopolis | Medium-High |
| Pokémon Yellow | Anime tie-in, more complete Pokédex on one cart | Medium |
How to Think About These Purchases
Each "third version" or enhanced pair follows the same basic pattern: take an existing pair of versions, add meaningful new content, and often rebalance or expand the postgame. The best ones (Platinum, Emerald, Crystal) are considered genuine improvements that most fans recommend over the original pair for a first playthrough of that generation.
The Buyer's Takeaway
If you're only buying one cartridge per generation and want the most complete experience, prioritize the enhanced version wherever one exists. If you're collecting for nostalgia tied to a specific childhood cartridge, the enhanced version's objective completeness matters less than which version you actually owned.
Some links on this page are eBay and Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, ShouldIBuyThisGame.com may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.