POKÉMON VERSION COMPARISON / GEN 9
Pokémon Scarlet vs Violet: Which Paldea Version Is Better?
The current generation's version split leans harder into thematic storytelling than most of its predecessors.
The Past-vs-Future Theme
Scarlet and Violet split their box legendaries (Koraidon vs Miraidon) along an explicit past-versus-future theme that extends to an entire category of exclusive "Paradox Pokémon" — ancient prehistoric-styled forms in Scarlet, futuristic robotic-styled forms in Violet — a more thoroughly integrated exclusive-content theme than most earlier version pairs attempted.
Professor and Story Exclusives
Each version also features a different lead professor character tied into its past/future theming, along with the usual species and legendary exclusives, giving Scarlet and Violet a slightly more distinct narrative flavor between versions than immediate predecessors like Sword/Shield.
Which to Buy in 2026
Pick based on whether the ancient/Paradox or futuristic/Paradox aesthetic appeals more to you — that's the throughline connecting the legendary, professor, and Paradox Pokémon exclusives in each version. Both share the same core Paldea open world and story otherwise.
Where to Buy: Scarlet & Violet
Some links on this page are eBay and Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, ShouldIBuyThisGame.com may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.