POKÉMON VERSION COMPARISON / GEN 4 REMAKE
Pokémon Brilliant Diamond vs Shining Pearl: Which Remake to Buy?
A faithful, chibi-style remake of the original Sinnoh pair, with the version-exclusive formula intact.
Version Exclusives
Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl mirror the original Diamond/Pearl split with Dialga and Palkia as box legendaries, along with the same fossil and species exclusives as the DS originals, rebuilt in a distinctive chibi-style art direction that proved divisive among longtime fans.
What's Notably Missing
Unlike Platinum, these remakes don't include the Distortion World's expanded content or the Battle Frontier, sticking closely to the original Diamond/Pearl scope rather than Platinum's enhanced version. That's worth knowing if you were hoping for a modernized Platinum experience specifically.
Which to Buy in 2026
Choose based on your preferred box legendary; the versions are otherwise nearly identical. If you specifically want the Distortion World and Battle Frontier content, the original DS Platinum cartridge remains the more complete Sinnoh experience, even without modern visuals.
Where to Buy: BDSP
Some links on this page are eBay and Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, ShouldIBuyThisGame.com may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.