BUYER'S DECISION FRAMEWORK / REMAKES

Original Nostalgia vs Modern Remake: Replay the Original or Buy the Remaster?

Resident Evil, Final Fantasy VII, Link's Awakening and more have all gotten major remakes. The right answer isn't always "buy the new one."

When the Remake Is the Better Buy

Remakes like Resident Evil 2 and Resident Evil 4 substantially rebuilt their source material with modern controls, updated horror pacing, and quality-of-life improvements that most players genuinely prefer over the originals today. When a remake is this thorough, it's usually the better purchase for actually playing the game rather than experiencing it as history.

When the Original Still Wins

Some remakes take real creative liberties that change the tone or pacing of the source material in ways longtime fans don't universally prefer — this varies significantly by title and is worth researching before assuming newer automatically means better. Original hardware and cartridges also carry collecting value that a remake simply can't replicate, regardless of gameplay quality.

The Verdict

If you want the best possible way to experience a story or gameplay loop today, research the specific remake's reputation rather than assuming it's automatically superior. If you're collecting for nostalgia, historical accuracy, or the physical hobby itself, the original remains the more meaningful purchase regardless of how good the remake is.

Some links on this page are eBay and Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, ShouldIBuyThisGame.com may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.