GAME VS GAME / ZELDA SHOWDOWN · ZELDA TURNS 40 IN 2026
Zelda: Ocarina of Time vs A Link to the Past: Which Zelda Is Best?
Two games that regularly trade places at the top of "greatest games ever" lists, from two different eras of the same franchise.
Two Different Templates for the Series
A Link to the Past established the overworld/dungeon structure and top-down design language that defined 2D Zelda for decades afterward. Ocarina of Time did the same job for 3D Zelda, introducing the targeting system (Z-targeting) that became the industry standard for 3D action games well beyond just Zelda titles.
Which Aged Better
A Link to the Past's 2D presentation ages gracefully in the way pixel art generally does, with tight, uncompromised design. Ocarina of Time's 3D visuals show their age more visibly, but its dungeon design and pacing are still frequently cited as some of the best the series has ever produced, even by players encountering it for the first time decades later.
Which to Buy First
If you prefer 2D design and want the series' foundational overworld structure, start with A Link to the Past. If you want the game most directly responsible for shaping how 3D action-adventure games control, start with Ocarina of Time. Zelda's 40th anniversary this year makes either purchase timely.
Where to Buy
Some links on this page are eBay and Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, ShouldIBuyThisGame.com may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.