CONSOLE VS CONSOLE / 5TH GENERATION
Nintendo 64 vs Sega Saturn: The Forgotten 5th-Gen Rivalry
PS1 dominated the conversation at the time. Two other consoles quietly built some of the era's most interesting libraries.
Two Very Different "Second Place" Stories
N64 sold respectably and built a smaller but very high-quality first-party library around cartridges, four-player multiplayer, and 3D design that's still cited as genre-defining. Saturn sold worse than either competitor in the West and leaned into complex 2D-friendly hardware that made it a favorite for fighters and shooters, especially in Japan, at the cost of broad third-party support.
Playability and Cost Today
N64 cartridges don't degrade and the console has a large, well-documented modding and repair community. Saturn's Western library is comparatively thin and often expensive for the best titles, though importing Japanese Saturn games and a region-compatible unit can meaningfully lower the cost of entry for the right buyer.
Which to Buy
N64 is the easier, more broadly satisfying purchase for most collectors. Saturn is a rewarding second or third console specifically for players chasing 2D fighting games and shoot-'em-ups who are comfortable navigating the import market.
Where to Buy: N64 & Saturn
Some links on this page are eBay and Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, ShouldIBuyThisGame.com may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.