CONSOLE VS CONSOLE / 6TH GENERATION · GAMECUBE TURNS 25 IN 2026

GameCube vs PS2: Which Should You Collect in 2026?

GameCube hits 25 this September. Its collector reputation has grown steadily since launch, even as PS2 kept the sales crown.

Breadth vs Curation

PS2 is still the broadest single 6th-gen purchase — more games, more genres, cheaper on average per title given how many were made. GameCube's library is far smaller but weighted heavily toward first-party Nintendo output that's aged extremely well: Metroid Prime, Wind Waker, and Melee are still actively discussed and played today, not just remembered fondly.

Format and Durability

GameCube's mini-DVD discs are physically smaller than standard PS2 DVDs, which kept load times short, and the format has generally proven durable. PS2's laser assembly is the console's known long-term wear item; GameCube's optical drive is comparatively less discussed as a failure point, though both benefit from buying tested units.

Which to Collect

If you want one console that covers the most ground, PS2 remains the pick. If you're specifically chasing Nintendo's first-party output from this era — and you're comfortable with a much smaller shelf of games — GameCube rewards a more focused collection, and its 25th anniversary this September makes 2026 a natural year to start.

Some links on this page are eBay and Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, ShouldIBuyThisGame.com may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.