HANDHELD VS HANDHELD / '90S UNDERDOGS

Sega Game Gear vs Atari Lynx: The Best "Failed" Color Handheld

Both handhelds beat Game Boy on paper. Both lost anyway, for remarkably similar reasons.

Similar Ambitions, Similar Problems

Both handhelds offered color, backlit screens years ahead of Game Boy's monochrome display, and both paid for it with dramatically worse battery life — a trade-off that mattered enormously to the kids and parents actually buying these devices in the early '90s. Both also lost their commercial battle to Game Boy's much longer battery life and larger, more consistent third-party library.

Different Technical Identities

Lynx notably supported hardware-based scaling and rotation effects unusual for a handheld of its era, and its comfortable, ambidextrous design was ahead of its time ergonomically. Game Gear leaned on its close relationship to Genesis, with several games sharing DNA between the two platforms, giving it a slightly more familiar library for Sega fans.

The Collector's Consideration

Both handhelds are known in the repair community for capacitor issues that develop over decades and can affect display or power performance if left unaddressed — a bigger maintenance consideration than most monochrome handhelds from the same era. Budget for this on either purchase, or buy from a seller who's already addressed it.

Which to Buy

Both are worthwhile curiosities for collectors interested in handheld history rather than daily-driver purchases. Lynx has a smaller but more technically unusual library; Game Gear's larger, Genesis-adjacent library gives it slightly broader appeal for most collectors.

Some links on this page are eBay and Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, ShouldIBuyThisGame.com may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.