HANDHELD VS HANDHELD
Game Boy vs Game Boy Color: Which Classic Handheld to Buy?
The upgrade that didn't obsolete its predecessor — GBC plays nearly the entire original Game Boy library too.
Backward Compatibility Changes the Calculus
Game Boy Color plays the vast majority of original Game Boy cartridges in addition to its own exclusive color library, which makes it the more practical single purchase for most buyers — one handheld effectively covers two generations of games. The original DMG Game Boy's screen is monochrome and, like the GBA that followed, has no backlight, making it genuinely hard to see without good external lighting.
Where the Original Still Has an Edge
The original Game Boy's brick-like design has an undeniable nostalgia pull for players who grew up with that exact shape, and its simpler hardware makes it a popular base for screen-mod projects that add a modern backlit or IPS display while keeping the original's exact form factor. If you're planning to mod anyway, starting with a cheap original unit can make more sense than starting with a GBC.
Which to Buy
For straightforward day-to-day playability, Game Boy Color is the clear pick thanks to its backward compatibility and color library. Buy an original DMG Game Boy specifically for nostalgia display purposes or as a mod project base, not as your primary way to actually play games.
Where to Buy: Game Boy & GBC
Some links on this page are eBay and Amazon affiliate links. If you buy through them, ShouldIBuyThisGame.com may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.